Scarlett Bentley and Cole Mueller on Temptation Island Season 2: Everything You Need to Know
Updated On : 6:41 am ET , Friday, 10 April 2026
Never Miss Your Chance to Audition!
Join our WhatsApp Channel for exclusive casting calls and audition alerts!
Join NowOn paper, they look like the perfect power couple — ambitious, fitness-focused, and always building something together. But after two years of dating, Scarlett Bentley and Cole Mueller are questioning if shared goals are enough when trust keeps slipping through the cracks.
Scarlett Bentley (29) and Cole Mueller (27) are one of the four real couples testing their relationship on Netflix’s Temptation Island Season 2 (overall Season 10), which premiered with all 9 episodes on April 10, 2026.
Their story mixes success with subtle cracks: Cole’s habit of telling “little lies” to avoid confrontation has created a trust gap that Scarlett wants to close for good.
This article dives into their full backstory, the trust and communication issues that brought them to the island, their specific ground rules, and live updates as the season unfolds.
Quick Facts about Scarlett & Bentley
| Name | Age | Occupation | Key Highlights |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scarlett Bentley | 29 | Marketing agency owner | Fitness lover, former Below Deck Sailing Yacht stew, seeks deeper trust & transparency |
| Cole Mueller | 27 | Real estate agent/developer, entrepreneur | Avoids confrontation, works on being more grounded |
They are appearing on Netflix’s Temptation Island Season 2, the full-season binge everyone is talking about right now.
Who Is Cole Mueller on Temptation Island?
Cole Mueller is 27 and works as a real estate agent, developer, and entrepreneur. He and Scarlett share a love for the gym, travel, and building businesses side-by-side — from joint workouts to planning new ventures.
Cole’s main challenge is his tendency to tell small white lies to dodge uncomfortable conversations. He has admitted he wants to work on being “more grounded in his own skin as a man” and learning to love himself fully during this experience.
His Instagram (@colemueller8) features couple trips to places like Lake Tahoe, New York, and Mexico, showing the adventurous side they enjoy together.
Who Is Scarlett Bentley on Temptation Island?
Scarlett Bentley is 29 and owns a marketing agency. She previously appeared as a stew on Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 3, bringing a confident and driven energy to the villa.
Scarlett is fitness-oriented and often shares workout content and travel photos on her Instagram (@scarlettbentley).
She believes challenging experiences lead to the greatest growth and hopes the show helps them build stronger trust, transparency, and communication. Scarlett wants to feel truly grounded in the relationship and is open about addressing the trust issues caused by Cole’s little lies.
Scarlett and Cole’s Relationship: Why Are They on Temptation Island?
Scarlett and Cole have been together for two years and share many common interests — hitting the gym, developing businesses, and enjoying an active lifestyle. On the surface, they seem like a strong match, but a persistent trust gap has emerged.
The core issue? Cole often tells “little lies” to avoid confrontation, which has left Scarlett questioning transparency in their relationship. Their biggest fear isn’t necessarily physical cheating, but emotional distance or losing each other amid the temptations.
Unlike some couples who entered with no rules, Scarlett and Cole set clear boundaries: no physical cheating and be respectful, while still allowing some fun. They see the island as a chance to strengthen communication and prove they’re meant to last.
Scarlett has shared: “I hope we can work on building trust, improving transparency, and strengthening our communication.” Cole echoes the desire for personal growth during the process.
What Happened to Scarlett and Cole on Temptation Island Season 2?
Scarlett entered the women’s villa with 12 single men, while Cole entered the men’s villa surrounded by 12 single women.
Their pre-set ground rules were clear: no physical cheating and “have fun but be respectful.” However, their biggest concern wasn’t infidelity — it was emotional distance and growing apart.
On the island, Cole tried hard to resist temptation and prove his trustworthiness. Scarlett, on the other hand, quickly formed a strong emotional connection with one of the tempters (Bradley), who shared her spiritual side and made her feel heard in ways she hadn’t with Cole. This highlighted the communication and trust gaps they already had — especially Cole’s habit of telling “little lies” to avoid confrontation.
At the final bonfire, tensions peaked when Cole admitted he had violated Scarlett’s trust by reading her journal during a visit to the women’s villa. Scarlett realized she had been settling and felt there was no path forward for meaningful change.
Are Scarlett and Cole Still Together After Temptation Island?
No — Scarlett and Cole are not together.
At the final bonfire, Cole expressed that he wanted to leave the island with Scarlett and continue working on the relationship. However, Scarlett chose to leave alone. She explained that she didn’t believe things would be drastically different after the experience and decided it was time to walk away.
Their story became one of the more emotional and nuanced arcs of Season 2 — a couple with many shared interests (fitness, ambition, and travel) who ultimately realized their trust and communication issues ran too deep to overcome in the villa.
Follow their Instagrams for any post-show updates:
Cole Mueller: @colemueller8
Scarlett Bentley: @scarlettbentley
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: How old are Scarlett and Cole on Temptation Island?
A: Scarlett Bentley is 29 and Cole Mueller is 27. They are one of the four couples on Netflix’s Temptation Island Season 2, which premiered April 10, 2026.
Q2: What does Cole Mueller do for work?
A: Cole Mueller is a real estate agent, developer, and entrepreneur.
Q3: What does Scarlett Bentley do for work?
A: Scarlett Bentley owns a marketing agency. She previously appeared on Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 3.
Q4: Why did Scarlett and Cole go on Temptation Island?
A: After two years together, they share many interests but struggle with trust issues, mainly due to Cole telling “little lies” to avoid confrontation. They want to build stronger transparency, communication, and emotional security.
Q5: Where can I watch Scarlett and Cole on Temptation Island?
A: All 9 episodes of Temptation Island Season 2 are available now on Netflix.
Scarlett and Cole represent the polished, ambitious couple whose biggest battle is internal — can they turn shared success into unbreakable trust, or will the island expose cracks they can’t repair?
