Jenna Lewis-Dougherty, the Survivor legend from Season 1 (Borneo) and All-Stars, made a highly anticipated return for Survivor Season 50 but became the first player voted out in the premiere episode.

Never Miss Your Chance to Audition!

Join our WhatsApp Channel for exclusive casting calls and audition alerts!

Join Now

In multiple post-elimination interviews, she has openly called out pregame alliances as the primary reason for her early exit, claiming they left her isolated and playing from the bottom from day one.

The milestone 50th season, themed around fan involvement and featuring a mix of returning players, saw Jenna on the Cila tribe. After the tribe lost the first immunity challenge—partly due to a poor performance by fellow vet Cirie Fields—Jenna targeted Cirie as a threat.

However, the vote swung against her, with all seven tribemates writing her name down. She pushed back against the edit’s portrayal that she was “playing too hard,” insisting the real issue was established social connections among other players.

In an exclusive interview with Entertainment Weekly, Jenna explained she had “zero pregame” alliances and “knew nobody out there,” putting her at a disadvantage compared to players with years of friendships or prior game history (like paired OGs such as Cirie and Ozzy, or others with close bonds).

She described the pregame culture involving FaceTime and Zoom calls as something she wasn’t part of, making her feel like the “odd man out” and a “sacrificial lamb.”

She also named names in other outlets, such as TVLine, where she claimed Christian Hubicki (from David vs.

Goliath) initially floated targeting Cirie but then flipped the narrative to make Jenna appear as the aggressor, setting her up for the blindside. In a Page Six interview and video, she directly called out the pregame alliances, highlighting how longstanding relationships doomed her chances in the high-stakes “death row” environment of Season 50.

Despite the shocking boot—after a 20+ year absence—Jenna expressed gratitude for her edit, calling it “like a love letter,” and indicated she’s open to returning someday.

She defended her aggressive early gameplay as necessary in such a stacked cast but lamented the social dynamics that sealed her fate before the game even fully began.

This early exit has sparked fan discussions on platforms like Reddit, where some speculate on the role of pregame dynamics despite producers’ warnings against them. Jenna’s candid comments underscore how modern Survivor returns often hinge on off-show relationships as much as in-game strategy.