During Vanderpump Rules Season 12 Reunion Part 1 (Episode 13, aired March 3, 2026), Demy Selem put an end to months of speculation by firmly denying any love triangle involving herself, Natalie Maguire, and her former fling Paulo.

Never Miss Your Chance to Audition!

Join our WhatsApp Channel for exclusive casting calls and audition alerts!

Join Now

The drama originated early in the season when Natalie was kicked out of SUR after screaming at her ex, Paulo — only for viewers to later learn that Paulo had also been involved with Demy. Rumors quickly spread that the two women were competing for the same man, fueling tension and side-eye within the group.

Host Andy Cohen revisited the incident on the reunion stage, prompting Demy to set the record straight in no uncertain terms.

“Honestly, he’s what brought us close,” Demy explained. “I feel like there’s this whole narrative out there that, like, me and Natalie are fighting over a guy, and that never happened.”

She clarified that Paulo was never a serious relationship for her — just a “fling.” When she made it clear she wasn’t interested in anything more committed, Paulo moved on and pursued Natalie. Far from creating rivalry, the situation actually strengthened Demy and Natalie’s friendship.

“We’re not fighting over a guy,” Demy emphasized. “That never happened. He’s actually the reason we got closer.”

The clarification came amid broader accusations of jealousy and misinformation. Kim Suarez had previously voiced discomfort over Natalie texting Marcus Johnson frequently, assuming it signaled interest in him.

Natalie pushed back, explaining the messages were only to thank Marcus for his support after the SUR ejection incident. She also addressed claims made on Lala Kent’s podcast, where she reiterated she had zero romantic interest in Marcus and accused others of pushing a false narrative.

The exchange highlighted how quickly misunderstandings — amplified by social media and group gossip — can spiral in the rebooted cast. Demy’s calm, direct denial helped diffuse one of the season’s lingering myths, showing growth and maturity among the new SURvers.

Fans on social media praised the moment as refreshing honesty: “Finally someone shuts down the love triangle BS,” one viewer posted. “Demy and Natalie’s friendship is actually the real storyline here.”

As the reunion continues in Part 2, the cast’s ability to address and correct rumors head-on signals a shift toward accountability in this new era of Vanderpump Rules. No love triangle, no lingering beef — just two friends who bonded over a shared ex who didn’t work out for either of them.

Watch Vanderpump Rules Reunion on Bravo Tuesdays at 9/8c, streaming next day on Peacock. Do you believe the love triangle narrative is officially dead? Let us know in the comments!