Are You My First? is a groundbreaking reality dating series captivating audiences with its unique premise of 21 virgin singles exploring love and intimacy in a tropical resort.

Never Miss Your Chance to Audition!

Join our WhatsApp Channel for exclusive casting calls and audition alerts!

Join Now

Hosted by The Bachelor alumni Colton Underwood and Kaitlyn Bristowe, the show has generated significant buzz, leading to increased interest in auditions for a potential Are You My First season 2 auditions.

As of August 5, 2025, Season 2 has not been officially announced, but the show’s recent debut suggests that casting calls will be on the horizon very soon and all the details are shared here periodically.

This guide provides a user-friendly roadmap for aspiring contestants, drawing from standard reality TV casting practices, particularly those of similar dating shows like Love Island USA. Whether you’re dreaming of finding love or sharing your story, this article will help you prepare for the audition process.

Why Audition for Are You My First season 2??

Auditioning for Are You My First season 2? offers a unique opportunity to step into the spotlight and explore romance in a way that’s rarely seen on television. Here are some compelling reasons to consider applying:

• Find Love in a Tropical Paradise: The show provides a judgment-free environment to connect with others who share similar values, set against a stunning tropical backdrop.
• Share Your Unique Story: Whether your choice to remain a virgin stems from religious beliefs, personal values, or waiting for the right person, the show offers a platform to celebrate your journey.
• Gain Visibility: Reality TV can open doors to new opportunities, from media exposure to potential career boosts, as seen with past reality stars.
• Personal Growth: Navigating romantic challenges on camera can help you learn more about yourself and build confidence in relationships.

The show’s focus on authenticity and diverse perspectives makes it an exciting opportunity for those ready to take a leap.

Who Can Apply for Are You My First season 2?

Based on the first season and typical reality TV casting standards, here’s what you’ll likely need to qualify for Are You My First? Season 2 auditions:

• Virginity: Applicants must be virgins, as this is the core premise of the show.
• Relationship Status: Must be single and not in a committed relationship or married.
• Age Range: Likely 18-30, aligning with the youthful demographic of dating shows like Love Island USA.
• Residency: US residents are preferred, but international applicants with valid passports for travel to the filming location may be considered.
• Availability: Must be available for several weeks of filming, typically in a tropical location.
• Background: No felony convictions or criminal records, as is standard for reality TV.

The show values diversity, so applicants from various backgrounds—whether in profession, culture, or reasons for celibacy—are encouraged to apply. For example, Season 1 featured contestants like a tech salesman, a dance teacher, and an NFL cheerleader, each with unique motivations.

How to Prepare for Are you my first Auditions 2026?

Getting ready for Are You My First? auditions requires thoughtful preparation to stand out in a competitive process. Here’s a step-by-step guide to help you shine:

Step 1: Understand the Show

• Watch Season 1 on Hulu to familiarize yourself with the format, challenges, and contestant dynamics. This will help you tailor your application to the show’s tone.
• Note the types of stories featured (e.g., religious convictions, waiting for true love) to understand what producers are looking for.

Step 2: Craft Your Story

• Reflect on your reasons for remaining a virgin. Are they tied to faith, personal values, or emotional readiness? Be ready to share this authentically.
• Consider what you’re seeking in a partner and why the show’s format appeals to you.
• Practice articulating your story in a concise, engaging way for your application and potential interviews.

Step 3: Create a Standout Application & Upload

• Photos: Prepare high-quality headshots and full-body photos that showcase your personality and style.
• Video Submission: Record a 1-2 minute video introducing yourself, sharing your story, and explaining why you want to be on Are You My First?. Use good lighting, a quiet setting, and let your charisma shine.
• Personal Details: Be ready to provide basic information like age, occupation, hometown, and relationship history.
• Once you are done with this part, you need to fill out the application form & upload video on audition link which will be shared soon.

The Audition Process

While specific details for Season 2 auditions are not yet available, the process is likely to mirror standard reality TV casting, based on shows like Love Island USA. Here’s what to expect:

• Initial Application: Likely submitted through Hulu or a casting partner’s website, including your video and photos.
• Interviews: Producers will ask about your reasons for being a virgin, dating history, and comfort with on-camera romance.
• Callbacks: Finalists may be invited for further auditions to test chemistry and suitability for the show.
• Timeline: If Season 2 is greenlit, auditions could be announced within months of Season 1’s premiere, with filming potentially in mid-2026.

Tips from the Pros

To increase your chances of being selected, follow these expert tips drawn from reality TV casting advice:

• Be Authentic: Share your genuine story; producers value realness over a rehearsed persona.
• Show Personality: Your video should be energetic and engaging, reflecting who you are.
• Practice Common Questions: Be ready to answer:
  • Why have you chosen to remain a virgin?
  • What are you looking for in a partner?
  • Why do you want to be on Are You My First??
• Look Your Best: Dress appropriately for photos and videos to make a strong first impression.
• Be Open: The show focuses on personal and sensitive topics, so be comfortable discussing virginity and relationships respectfully.
• Leverage Social Media (Optional): An active, positive social media presence (e.g., Instagram, TikTok) can help producers notice you, though it’s not required.

What to Expect if Selected

If you make it through the audition process, here’s what you can anticipate:

• Filming in a Tropical Location: Expect to spend several weeks in a stunning resort, likely outside the US, as seen in Season 1.
• Living with Contestants: You’ll share a villa with other singles, fostering close connections and potential drama.
• Romantic Dates and Challenges: Participate in activities designed to spark romance, from intimate dates to group challenges.
• Constant Filming: Be prepared for 24/7 cameras, which means limited privacy and public exposure of your journey.
• Emotional Journey: Navigating relationships on camera can be intense but offers a chance for meaningful connections.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Conclusion

Are You My First? Season 2 auditions are an exciting opportunity for singles ready to share their stories and find love on a groundbreaking reality show.

While auditions have not yet been announced, preparing now by crafting your story, creating a compelling video, and staying updated on casting calls will give you a head start.