Alison Arngrim, the actress who brought the iconic mean girl Nellie Oleson to life on the beloved 1970s series Little House on the Prairie, recently shared a delightful behind-the-scenes story about her audition.

Never Miss Your Chance to Audition!

Join our WhatsApp Channel for exclusive casting calls and audition alerts!

Join Now

In a fresh interview highlighted by People magazine (published January 17, 2026), Arngrim recalled how her spot-on delivery had Michael Landon (who starred as Charles Ingalls and also created, produced, and directed much of the show) and the producers cracking up so hard they had tears streaming down their faces.

At just 11 years old, Arngrim initially auditioned for the sweeter Ingalls sisters roles (like Laura or Mary) but didn’t land them. When the show got picked up and needed more characters, she was called back to try out for the snobby, spoiled Nellie Oleson. She prepared a monologue from the early episode “Country Girls,” where Nellie brags about her fancy home and luxurious lifestyle—complete with lines about having three sets of dishes (one for every day, one for Sunday, and one special set that’s never used).

Practicing at home, her dad burst out laughing at her bratty, over-the-top performance and told her, “Don’t change a thing—just go in and do it exactly like that.”

Following his advice, she walked into the room with Landon and a few producers, launched into the speech straight-faced, and delivered it perfectly. The reaction was immediate: everyone erupted in hysterical laughter. “They are laughing through this whole thing, so hard. Tears, elbowing each other in the ribs,” Arngrim remembered. She even heard them still giggling as she left the room.

The audition was so convincing and funny that she was hired on the spot—her agent called before she even got home to schedule a wardrobe fitting. Arngrim credits that natural comedic timing for securing the role that would make her a TV legend as the show’s ultimate bully and fan-favorite villain.

This charming anecdote resurfaced during reflections at the Little House on the Prairie Final 50th Anniversary Reunion event in December 2025, as the cast celebrated the show’s milestone. It’s a fun reminder of how Arngrim’s flair for Nellie’s exaggerated snobbery instantly clicked with the team, turning what could have been a standard tryout into an unforgettable, laugh-filled moment.

This quick, feel-good read captures the joy of classic TV magic—perfect for a short scroll or coffee break!